Friday Saturday Random 10: Shuffle vs. Genius............

Today's Friday Saturday (I said in my first post I'm a bad procrastinator) and it's time for another Random 10: Shuffle vs. Genius.

Starting Song: Is There A Switch For That - 1990s



Shuffle Playlist................................Genius Playlist
1. Is There A Switch For That -.............1. Is There A Switch For That -
.......1990s.................................................1990s
2. Jet Boy, Jet Girl - The Damned.........2. A Train Roars - The Horrors
3. London Girl - The Pogues.................3. Pump Up The Volume - Art Brut
4. Mensforth Hill - The Clash.....W.........4. This Month, Day 10 - CSS
5. Lady Stardust - David Bowie.............5. Black Magic - Jarvis Cocker
6. Help The Aged - W...........................6. Tight Fit - New Young Pony Club
.......Pulp (Peel Sessions)
7. Ob-la-di Ob-la-da - The Beatles.........7. The Wrath Of Marcie -
.................................................................The Go! Team
8. Racecar Driver - Girl In A Coma........8. Guilt By Association - Louis XIV
9. Ziggy Stardust - Seu Jorge................9. Scratch Your Name -
.................................................................Noisettes
10. First Night Back In London -.............10. The Bad Thing - Arctic Monkeys
..........The Clash

Track by track comparison after the jump.

Jet Boy, Jet Girl vs. A Train Roars: This one goes to shuffle. It's basically The Damned doing one of my favorite songs in the world (Jet Boy, Jet Girl/Ca Plane Pour Moi) against one of my least favorite Horror's songs. Definite no brainer.

London Girl vs. Pump Up The Volume: Shuffle wins again here. I'm planning a post about second albums and how bands can end up de-fanging them for a "more mature" sound. I think that's kind of what happened to Art Brut's second album. It still has really good, fun, dirty lyrics but it's so much less brash and the brashness is really what made me love them in the first place. Also, I'm happy my itunes picked a Pogues song from Rum, Sodomy, and the Lash because it went through a really long phase of only picking songs from Peace and Love which was really unfortunate.

Mensforth Hill vs. This Month, Day 10: I'm really surprised I found Mensforth Hill on Youtube. Again Shuffle has caused me to pick a non-Clash song over a Clash song. Last week it was because of a demo and this week it was because of one of the least listenable tracks on Sandinista! (which is my fave Clash album, but I'm not so into the 'other tracks played backwards' dubs). I think Even a second album CSS track could have won this one. This one goes to genius.

Lady Stardust vs. Black Magic: I think this is going to have to be a draw. I love both of these songs. A lot. Lady Stardust was my favorite Ziggy song for a long time (until the 'it was cold, and it rained...' part of Five Years totally won me over). Black Magic was probably the first song off of Jarvis' solo record that I liked. Most of the others had to grow on me. It's pretty much a perfect song, coincidentally about how hard it is to write a great song and how it's a kind of x-factor. So I can't choose...

Help The Aged (peel sessions) vs. Tight Fit: So I think it's pretty obvious that shuffle is going to win today. An amazing Pulp song played live at John Peel's birthday party is pretty hard to beat, especially when it's competition is a kind of mediocre New Young Pony Club song.

Ob-la-di Ob-la-da vs. The Wrath Of Marcie: I'm so indecisive today. I actually like both songs pretty much equally. The Beatles doing ska always has a special place in my heart and Wrath of Marcie is my favorite Go! Team song. I'm going to give this to shuffle though because genius picked a Go! team song last week and has a bad habit of always picking the same songs/songs by the same artist repeatedly. Maybe that's my fault for overlistening to stuff...but whatever...

Racecar Driver vs. Guilt By Association: I thought I was going to love Girl In A Coma's album because of how much I loved Clumsy Sky. It kind of left me cold though. I definitely need to listen to it more. It has potential but at the moment I prefer the catchier Louis XIV song so genius wins here.

Ziggy Stardust vs. Scratch Your Name: Shuffle wins again. Scratch Your Name isn't my favorite Noisettes songs. Sometimes their songs get kinda proggy, I guess is the word, like Bridge to Canada. I prefer their songs that are brighter and stripped down, like Don't Give Up, Sister Rosetta, and I Will Never Fall In Love Again. So this one's going to shuffle and Seu Jorge's gorgeous cover of Ziggy.

First Night Back In London vs. The Bad Thing: I think The Bad Thing is one of the AM's more forgettable/mediocre songs and First Night Back In London is one of my favorite weird, non-album Clash songs. It has great rhythm/syncopation and has dark, kind of noir-ish imagery and tone. Shuffle wins yet again.

This week shuffle takes it 6-2 so the overall score is tied up, Shuffle - 1, Genius - 1.